Reasons why the UK may not be granted a Brexit adequacy decision

Image depicting deal or no-deal Brexit

Share This Post

As was discussed on a recent webinar, there’s some challenges ahead regarding GDPR and the end of the Brexit transition period – i.e. what happens from 1st January 2021 in terms of what might happen if the EU and UK can’t agree to a position on GDPR compliance, which in turn will have impact on EU to UK data transfers. In the case of a no-deal GDPR Brexit the UK will be treated like other non-EEA countries which will ultimately have implications for EU to UK data flows, the need for UK businesses to answer to other data protection regulations (not just the ICO) and have EU representatives if they process EU citizen data.

The advice right now is probably prepare for a no-deal Brexit and consider the implications for your business if you have dealings with EU data. But even if a deal is sorted, there are still some questions about whether the EU will grant a GDPR adequacy decision (one of the non-EEA transfers/processing safeguards required by GDPR). This may seem silly given the UK has been operating under the EU GDPR since it came into force in 2018, but there are a number of issues which could mean the UK won’t get an adequacy decision:

  • there are exemptions in DPA2018 relating to data processed for immigration purposes which could mean non-UK data subjects data won’t necessarily be processed according to EU standards
  • the UK’s data retention provisions for electronic telecommunications data are not compatible with the EU’s expectation of implementation of the relevant EU regulation (the “EU acquis” which means it should be implemented the same across all EU member states)
  • questions around mass surveillance and the UK’s data protection framework relating to national security and processing by law enforcement agencies

And now there’s another reason: the UK government’s National Data Strategy which according to an article in the Guardian hints at some plans going forward which could also impact adequacy with the EU raising concern about specifically what the UK government is planning.

Whilst the UK government aren’t suggesting that we shouldn’t have adequacy, the strategy does suggest some activities that need to change due to constraints in current legislation and if the Guardian article is to be believed, there are elements of the UK government who think GDPR is too restrictive and with statements like the GDPR creating “legal barriers (real and perceived)” and suggestions that something needs to be done to address the Schrems II issues with transfers/processing the US, it’s no surprise that the EU are concerned and want some explanations on plans.

Given that the Prime Minister suggests he wants all Brexit negotiations to be finalised by mid-October, we shouldn’t have too long to wait to find out what this all means in practice.

More To Explore

Eat. Sleep. GDPR. Repeat.

We live and breathe GDPR and ePrivacy compliance, so you don’t have too. Our GDPR UNLIMITED helpline is all about offering you help and support, whenever you need it most. As well as the unlimited helpline, you get up to 4 hours “hands-on” help each month, which we can configure to help you in anyway you need such as a GDPR review, or acting as your DPO.

As well as the unlimited helpline and hands-on help you get GDPR and privacy updates, access to our GDPR knowledge centre and webinars.

Unlimited email & phone support

Unlimited email and phone support. Email or organise a voice call as often as you need each month.​

Up to 4 hours "hands-on" help per month

We use these "hands-on" hours to do the GDPR work for you, such as reviews, acting as your DPO, checking DPIA, dealing with breaches, training your staff, etc. (Additional hours: £100+VAT per hour)

Online resources

Our Knowledge Centre gives you access to information, guidance, topic related guides and other tools to support your GDPR and PECR compliance

Updates, alerts & briefings

We provide updates and alerts and a monthly compliance briefing. You can either sign into the Knowledge Centre or sign up via email to receive an email every time we add a new update or alert

DPO services

Whether mandated or not we can act as your Data Protection Officer (DPO) and manage your day to day compliance

Webinars, workshops & training

Whether updates on the latest issue, workshops or team training, it's all included in your monthly retainer.

LIKE WHAT YOU'RE READING? join our email list

Sign up for monthly briefings and the occasional emails about our webinars and services

Want to know more about how we use your data? Check out our privacy policy