Greek DPA -v- PwC highlights consent not suitable lawful basis for employee data

Share This Post

The Greek equivalent of the ICO have issued a €150,000 fine of PwC for having the wrong lawful basis for processing for their employee’s data. PwC required employees to consent to the processing of their data when other lawful basis were more applicable; furthermore, PwC had also failed to properly document their lawful basis for processing and therefore failing the GDPR’s accountability principle.

Consent as the lawful basis

Consent should always be thought of as a binary choice, a yes or no, so asking employees to consent to the processing means employees could always say no, and given that in terms of HR processing it’s usually necessary to process an employees personal data to meet contractual obligations (e.g. payroll) or legal obligations relating to employment law, it is not appropriate that consent was sought as the lawful basis of processing. Indeed, given that the processing would carry on either if an employee said no or that it would not be in the interest of the employee to say no, it therefore fails the consent test in terms of the GDPR requiring consent to be freely given.

Of course, this is a lesson to anyone using consent as the lawful basis and to ensure that it is the most appropriate (and lawful) basis for processing personal data.

Are your HR processes compliant?

Wondering whether you’ve got the right lawful basis for processing for your employees? Well, best check – remember consent is highly unlikely to be appropriate for normal HR activities, but may be needed for some additional processing activities not covered by general employment. You should be looking at contract, legal obligation and legitimate interest as the most likely lawful basis to pursue.

And, don’t forget you need documentary evidence of which lawful basis you’ve chosen as well.

An English summary of the case available here.

More To Explore

Eat. Sleep. GDPR. Repeat.

We live and breathe GDPR and ePrivacy compliance, so you don’t have too. Our GDPR UNLIMITED helpline is all about offering you help and support, whenever you need it most. As well as the unlimited helpline, you get up to 4 hours “hands-on” help each month, which we can configure to help you in anyway you need such as a GDPR review, or acting as your DPO.

As well as the unlimited helpline and hands-on help you get GDPR and privacy updates, access to our GDPR knowledge centre and webinars.

Unlimited email & phone support

Unlimited email and phone support. Email or organise a voice call as often as you need each month.​

Up to 4 hours "hands-on" help per month

We use these "hands-on" hours to do the GDPR work for you, such as reviews, acting as your DPO, checking DPIA, dealing with breaches, training your staff, etc. (Additional hours: £100+VAT per hour)

Online resources

Our Knowledge Centre gives you access to information, guidance, topic related guides and other tools to support your GDPR and PECR compliance

Updates, alerts & briefings

We provide updates and alerts and a monthly compliance briefing. You can either sign into the Knowledge Centre or sign up via email to receive an email every time we add a new update or alert

DPO services

Whether mandated or not we can act as your Data Protection Officer (DPO) and manage your day to day compliance

Webinars, workshops & training

Whether updates on the latest issue, workshops or team training, it's all included in your monthly retainer.

LIKE WHAT YOU'RE READING? join our email list

Sign up for monthly briefings and the occasional emails about our webinars and services

Want to know more about how we use your data? Check out our privacy policy